Search

Psychological Support in the ED

Author: Charlotte Davies / Editor: Nikki Abela / Codes: SLO7 / Published: 25/02/2025

We know that Emergency Department (EDs) across the world are struggling, and the huge amount of pressure that is putting on all of the staff. RCEM is doing their best to raise awareness of the problems, and I for one, am glad to be part of a college that continuously challenges the rulers of this country. But RCEM can’t solve the crowding problems, so for the next few weeks (or if we’re honest, years), we’re going to have to live with them. But how? We don’t have all the answers, but here are some thoughts – but more importantly, an acknowledgement that we are in this all together, and we’re here for each other. We’d really really appreciate your thoughts, comments and wisdom – together, we’ll get through this. 

Psychological Support In the first wave, the whole world was with us, the NHS.  The  freebies heading our way persist and some support still exists, but a lot is different. We know it is hugely demanding both physically and mentally for all staff, with lots of moral injury, on a background of exhaustion. As individuals we need to look after ourselves, and our team, whilst recognising the positive effects of stress! We’re in the active phase, and what we do there will help in the recovery phase. RCEMLearning has lots of wellbeing resources available here and RCEM has an excellent whole page of resources highlighted here, as well as many key documents from the sustainable working group including the wellness compendium, when a colleague dies – and much more. There’s many resources already in existence – one of many twitter threads starts here, liason psych advice here, fabulous learning from excellence summary, pre-hospital advice here, and there’s a useful BMJ summary of self care here too.  Even HEE have a separate wellbeing programme, and the London School of Paediatrics created a wellbeing book! Other places have released lots of guidance too including Cardiff intensive care here, and there’s an e-learning package on psychological wellbeing from WRAPEM, and another from University of Nottingham here. Here are our top tips for advice to give your team, and yourself.

  1. Be in top physical form

We know sleep (here and here covid specific here) nutrition and rest are really important, especially as we have a lot of video call fatigue. They probably have a good effect on our immunity. View our previous articles (compendium here) already and highlight them to your non EM colleagues. RCEM is really clear that now, more than ever, we need to look after ourselves, and everyone else, including our patients. It’s also worth mentioning that all the hand washing can cause havoc with your skin (although what all these people were doing beforehand I do not know)! Moisturise well! If your hands have started to crack, these tips from a dermatologist are fab, and BAD released a statement too.

  1. Recognise and manage your stress

Read the RCEMLearning Stress Blog. Don’t just read it though, talk about stress and how to manage it with all your colleagues both in EM and out of EM. I delivered the simple stress lecture – and opened by saying “How do you know when I’m stressed”. At least 5 accurate signs were presented. When I asked “how do you help when I’m stressed”, the room went silent. By talking about it, it really helped normalise the potential of stress. Everyone in the room was stressed about coronavirus on about a 7-8/10 – apart from one person who hadn’t been in the clinical environment, so maybe we’re not helping ourselves! A stress management course online starts soon! Remind People to be Kind: Some stress comes from not being able to help. Encourage non front line staff to think about their neighbours and community initiatives. Initiative to help GP services could be used in hospitals – engage your patient participation group? It’s not just everyone else that needs to be kind – leaders need to be kind too.

There’s lots of mindfulness apps available here with discounts / freebies for NHS staff, and a summary for “NHS people” here. There’s a new twitter handle just for wellness – @19_wellness with a supporting facebook group, and an fab  overview of everything with bags of awesome resources from NHS in mind. There’s a new PHP supportline available too. There’s some specific resources around reducing coronavirus related anxiety and some meditations here (found from twitter). The “young person” resources might be good for the young or the old, and this imagined section resources is ideal for children. There’s also some more generic wellbeing tips available from “live life to the full” with some lovely posters for HCPs here, and there will be some regular caring4nhspeople webinairs, as well as lots of blogs and resources from the Maudsley. You’d be surprised if we didn’t mention resilience – have  a look at this resilience blog from T2 here. Hypnosis is clearly very beneficial here – have a look at some of the relaxations on NHS in mind, or the 5min relax and recover. More will be coming from ISH – some here already.

  1. Recognise and manage everyone else’s stress

Consider why people are anxious – just because you’re not (although you probably are!), doesn’t mean they shouldn’t be – read this article on recognising anxieties.  Maybe they don’t know from a patient perspective how ventilation works? This is discussed by St Emlyns here.  Children might have different anxieties – discussed here. People might just be in a different spot to you – I think most people in EM have moved through the fear zone into the learning or growth zones – not everyone is there yet.

There’s a useful leaflet from Mind about reducing general anxiety, and an excellent article on managing your own mental health from BBC coronavirus. These resources will also be useful for your patients COVID related anxiety. This from the intensive care society starts by reminding us to make sure you only get updates once or twice a day. Encourage this from your team, to help them help themselves. Have some good email and especially whatsapp management strategies – remember whats app is often on people’s personal mobiles, so they can’t ignore it. If you check for updates every five seconds, you will burden yourself with anticipatory stress. Whilst you do this, only contact your nosey friends once or twice. We all know the people we mean – those who are only in touch when something bad happens, or they want “inside information”. They’ll take your time away, and suck you into making this a bigger drama than it is. It’s also worth remembering your wider team. Clinicians are aware of all the resources being thrown at them, but make sure the non clinical staff are too. The effects of stress on teams are widely known – do what you can to minimise it.

  1. Keep Laughing and Keep Leading

It’s OK to laugh. These are challenging times, yes, but Laughter can enhance immunity–  and we know it reduces stress. Social distancing doesn’t mean emotional distancing. Your team need you now more than ever – some great tips here. Who is self isolating and needs to check in? Who is poorly and needs a 5 min check in chat?

  1. Debrief Often

Debriefing is everyone’s responsibility, and you need to encourage your team to start doing it now – debriefs shouldn’t just be after cardiac arrest. Check in and debrief with yourself – some great tips here, and a non covid related debrief podcast here. Not all debriefing needs to be formal – I love the idea of a wobble room, and even just asking “how are you“, and not all debriefing needs to be after the event – consider a time out. Most of us have been debriefing for a while, but might run out of time, and the headspace. Contact your chaplaincy service, and any psychology services – ours are going to be running a daily debrief drop in session with our psychology colleagues to make sure night and day shift can attend. A “4 o-clock club” is a similar approach. For people new to debriefing, the “TAKE STOCK” principle will be useful, and there’s another useful COVID specific prompt here. There’s a trial of an online debriefing service here. A hot debrief is recommended, but not compulsory. It is an emotional release and a “lessons learned” review carried out there and then after the incident or exercise, when all the key people are still present and any lessons learned can immediately influence future events. Minor details aren’t lost because of time delay, or a later emphasis on the bigger issues. We have prompts available on our ED bereavement checklist to attempt to normalise the debrief process – often starting is the hardest part! The cold debrief structure is often similar to the simulation “debrief diamond” or an after action review. The resus team may be able to help arrange this. An alternative model for a cold debrief is one which focuses on the emotional impact of the event and the ways in which participants are coping with this, and potential lessons to be learnt are not addressed, to enable people to speak freely in a non-judgemental environment. This model might be particularly useful to support the psychological well-being of staff.

  1. Arrange Practical and Wellbeing Support

It’s the little things that make a day at work better or worse. Worrying about whether your period will start, or if you’ve got enough food at home won’t make it better. But what about if you need to shower after a patient coughs all over you? What about if you’re too tired to travel home? Practical ideas like a “fare box“, “too tired to travel home” box, peer support for all things, including grocery supply are useful. Of course, if there’s space in your hospital some porta-homes would be useful for staff isolating from family, or who can’t get transport to work. The extroverts might like some interaction – maybe a zoom quiz or something? We at LGT, had to go one step further, and our period SOS box has got organic supplies (thank you Freda), and a nice little bit of period specific relaxing (slow version here – if it helped you let us know!). The doctor sickness record we’ve been keeping has tick boxes for when you last completed a welfare check. Ideally we’ll do that every day. Pragmatically, we’re not sure. We’re encouraging our junior doctors to form welfare groups, so they can check in on themselves.

7.  Allow grief  Many trusts have banned visitors, even for the dying. This is leaving a lot of HCPs as the last person speaking to a dying patient- and this is taking a toll. We deliver people out of this world, as much as a midwife delivers them in – but it isn’t always easy. Take a moment to honour, and grieve for your patient who has died. We hope none of you have to grieve for friends or relatives, but you might have to. Un-doubtably you will have to support grieving relatives of patients. There are plenty of tips here from thegoodgrieftrust, and tips for for grieving children here. Not all deaths will be due to coronavirus, and other support societies do exist eg. brake for victims of road traffic accidents.

8. Support Family  Acknowledging that your doctor’s family is supporting them too is useful. This is a great letter from one trust. Using careful language is also important – and many using the right terminology around covid is important – original article here and twitter here.

9. Rest Well Resting is more than sleeping well. Resting is a chance to give everything to recover. We’ve made some suggestions on how reading can help, and some suggestions of what to do to help with holidays and we look forward to hearing your suggestions and additions too.

Other RCEM Learning Wellbeing Resources: We’ve signposted to the fabulous RCEM wellbeing compendium already. Do have a look at some of our other wellbeing resources – all available free of charge here.

Other Resources: HEE have created a wellbeing induction and strategy that piloted for the new transition to FY years. Some of the links they’ve highlighted are fabulous. We like: AOMRC CDC MindEd Intensive Care Society Practitioner Support and have used some of their suggestions to update noticeboards with healthy eating and financial wellbeing contributions – instead of just focussing on mental health.

We’ve been writing on, and talking about crowding for a long time – revisit our updated blogs here – and we won’t re-visit that, but we’ll just touch on some key wellbeing features.

General Psychological Support

As individuals we need to look after ourselves, and our team, whilst recognising the positive effects of stress! RCEMLearning has lots of wellbeing resources available here and RCEM has an excellent whole page of resources highlighted here as well as many key documents from the sustainable working group

We know resilience isn’t the answer to everything, and that we’re all fed up with being resilient. That’s true. But we also know there are protective factors to stop us getting burnt out, and whilst this isn’t the whole story, we need to do everything we can to keep ourselves safe. Seatbelts won’t save you from everything – but we still use them to do everything we can to keep ourselves safe.

What are we mitigating?

Our general suggestions are written with the aim of reducing moral injury, compassion fatigue and burnout – three different but linked conditions. workplace factors do contribute to all three of these- we are just focusing on personal factors. One could say we want to improve wellbeing (which is different to happiness – read here. How we improve wellbeing is difficult to evidence – wellness workshops don’t work (The Compassion Fatigue Workbook).

We all like things we can measure. Why not start with an assessment to see where YOU score for compassion fatigue, burnout and moral injury. The survey looks at the last 30 days. How do your colleagues do? Have a look at ProQOL here. As you do it, consider – ‘When we keep ourselves numbed out on adrenaline or overworking or cynicism, we don’t have an accurate internal gauge of ourselves and our needs’, Trauma Stewardship, Laura van Dernoot Lipsky.

Compassion Fatigue

“An occupational hazard affecting some of those who do their work well.” (pg. 9 The Compassion Fatigue Workbook, Françoise Mathieu) 

This is where repeated (i.e. cumulative) exposure to suffering causes emotional and physical exhaustion.1 It is similar to burnout, and often confused with it. Burnout is defined as chronic exhaustion resulting from the mental and physical demands of daily life, culminating in emotional fatigue, depersonalisation and perceived lack of accomplishment. Some say compassion fatigue is a type of burnout.2

Have a listen on your podcast player to the now archived Jan 2018 podcast from about 1hr 11min where, Caroline is an ED and PHEM consultant in Coventry talks about compassion fatigue. 

Compassion fatigue may initially present as an irritability with co-workers and feeling that you’re doing all. The work. You may start to avoid meetings and then get fatigued and exhausted at the end of the day. You become bitter at work, with guilt, resentment with eroded compassion. You may have an exaggerated sense of responsibility – I can’t leave. How often do we see this in EM? I can’t take my break the waiit is soooo long.

Fig.1

An impaired ability to make decisions – our colleagues may not be struggling with their seniority… but just suffering from compassion fatigue. 

Protective features include having control over work intensity and a variety of roles. Having a higher standard of care may increase the risk – but we wouldn’t suggest lowering standards! 

When compassion fatigue is present, it is harder to implement these protective features, making continued and worsening compassion fatigue more likely. To reduce likelihood of compassion fatigue we need to ensure coherent and supportive teams, periods of debrief and downtime after traumatic events, awareness of compassion fatigue, and mechanisms for patients to express gratitude.

Burnout

We’ve covered burnout in other blogs: Burnout, Burn-ED. The key bit is to get your protective factors present. 

Moral Injury

The term ‘moral injury’ has been used to describe the psychological effects of ‘bearing witness to the aftermath of violence and human carnage’ or failing to prevent outcomes which transgress deeply-held beliefs. The effects are cumulative and started before covid, although were compounded by covid.3,4

Moral Injury is covered well in this EMJ article by Esther Murray, St Emlyn’s and our October 2018 podcast covers it – available in archive form only.

There is an overlap between moral injury and PTSD, but it is possible to have one without the other and moral injury often doesn’t involve a threat to life. There is a moral injury distress scale – it would be interesting to assess this in our current workforce, but I worry it would highlight how much the unacceptable has had to become acceptable.5-7

Prevention is better than cure:

  • Social support
  • Ability to debrief with honest, open conversations8,9

 

General Strategies

1. You can not (at the moment) change the crowding problem. You can not change what has happened before your shift started. Stop investing any mental energy in trying to change the things you can not change. Please comment below with the things you can not change.

2. Be in top physical form

This counts as “putting your own oxygen mask on”. Hospitals will be crowded whether you cook yourself a nutritious meal or not.  View our previous articles (Wellness Compendium) already and highlight them to your non EM colleagues.

Sleep: Sleep is essential (here and here)
Nutrition: Eat well. Delivery meal boxes are still allowed. 

3. Recognise and manage your stress

Read the RCEMLearning Stress Blog. Don’t just read it though, talk about stress and how to manage it with all your colleagues both in EM and out of EM. I delivered the simple stress lecture – and opened by saying “How do you know when I’m stressed”. At least 5 accurate signs were presented. When I asked “how do you help when I’m stressed”, the room went silent. By talking about it, it really helped normalise the potential of stress. Does crowding cause you stress? 

Employ relaxation strategies – mindfulness, hypnosis (e.g. 5min relax and recover, ISH, NHS in mind). A full body scan exercise can be very useful.

4. Be Kind and Recognise and manage everyone else’s stress

Consider why people (colleagues, patients, relatives) are anxious – just because you’re not (although you probably are!), doesn’t mean they shouldn’t be – read this article on recognising anxieties.  Maybe they don’t know from a patient perspective how ventilation works? This is discussed by St Emlyn’s here.  Children might have different anxieties – discussed here. People might just be in a different spot to you .There’s a useful leaflet from Mind about reducing general anxiety, and an excellent article on managing your own mental health from BBC coronavirus

Be kind – it may seem obvious to you that a patient can temporarily move to the plaster room from the corridor for a PR – but not to the surgeons. Everyone is likely to be making decisions at maximum bandwidth (our blog about situational awareness). Be polite about other specialties (including GP) even if you think they’ve done something daft.

5. Debrief

We’re great at debriefing after a significant event, but should we be debriefing after crowded shifts? We have some debrief thoughts in our April 2020 podcast. Not all debriefing needs to be formal – I love the idea of a wobble room, and even just asking “how are you“, and not all debriefing needs to be after the event – consider a time out. The cold debrief structure is often similar to the simulation style debrief. 

The informal debrief in the coffee room is great – if both sides of the process have choice  in the process. Limited disclosure may help – start with the least traumatic information.

6. Arrange Practical and Wellbeing Support

Period boxes, “fare box“, “too tired to travel home” box, peer support for all things, including grocery supply, are useful. 

7. Identify what gives you positive energy

If you get joy from cooking – cook! If you get joy from seeing bizarre symptoms or drunk patients – see them, and gain that protective positive energy.

Hopefully, this has been a useful overview – please put your comments and suggestions and resources in the comments. 

References

  1. Crowe L. Identifying the risk of compassion fatigue, improving compassion satisfaction and building resilience in emergency medicine. Emergency Medicine Australasia, 2016, 28: 106–108.
  2. Hunsaker S, Chen HC, et al. Factors That Influence the Development of Compassion Fatigue, Burnout, and Compassion Satisfaction in Emergency Department Nurses. Journal of Nursing Scholarship, 2015, 47: 186-194.
  3. Murray E. Moral injury and paramedic practice. Journal of Paramedic Practice 2019 11:10, 424-425.
  4. Moral distress and moral injury. Recognising and tackling it for UK doctors. British Medical Association (BMA), 2021.
  5. Norman SB, Maguen S. Moral Injury. PTSD: National Center for PTSD, 2024.
  6. Moral Injury and Distress Scale (MIDS). PTSD: National Center for PTSD, 2024.
  7. Williamson V, et al. Moral injury: the effect on mental health and implications for treatment. The Lancet Psychiatry, Volume 8, Issue 6, 453 – 455.
  8. Murray E. Moral Injury during COVID-19. St Emlyn’s, 2021.
  9. Carley S. Podcast – Moral Injury in Emergency and Pre-hospital care with Esther Murray. St Emlyn’s, 2018.