Both present with similar symptoms and signs, but their anatomy is quite different. The secundum ASD is a defect in the centre of the atrial septum involving the foramen ovale. Partial AVSD is a defect of the atrioventricular septum.
Animation: Secundum ASD
Clinical features
Symptoms
None (commonly)
Recurrent chest infections/wheeze
Arrhythmias (fourth decade onwards)
Physical Signs
An ejection systolic murmur best heard at the upper left sternal edge – due to increased flow across the pulmonary valve because of the left-to-right shunt
A fixed and widely split second heart sound (often difficult to hear) – due to the right ventricular stroke volume being equal in both inspiration and expiration
With a partial AVSD, an apical pansystolic murmur from atrioventricular valve regurgitation
Investigations
Chest radiograph
Finding:
Cardiomegaly
Enlarged pulmonary arteries
Increased pulmonary vascular markings
ECG
Finding:
Secundum ASD – partial right bundle branch block is common (but may occur in normal children), right axis deviation due to right ventricular enlargement
Partial AVSD – a ‘superior’ QRS axis (mainly negative in AVF). This occurs because there is a defect of the middle part of the heart where the atrioventricular node is. The displaced node then conducts to the ventricles superiorly giving the abnormal axis
Echocardiography
Finding:
This will delineate the anatomy and is the mainstay of diagnostic investigations
Management
Children with significant ASD will require treatment. For secundum ASDs this is by cardiac catheterisation with insertion of an occlusion device but for partial AVSD surgical correction is required.
Treatment is usually undertaken at about 3-5 years of age in order to prevent right heart failure and arrhythmias in later life.