Subscribe to our newsletter to receive information on new and updated content

 

Words Matter

Warning

The content you’re about to read or listen to is at least two years old, which means evidence and guidelines may have changed since it was originally published. This content item won’t be edited but there will be a newer version published if warranted. Check the new publications and curriculum map for updates

Author: Darren Kilroy / Codes: CC1, CC5, CC6 / Published: 20/01/2015

In healthcare, we do love a label, and we rush to find one as soon as we possibly can. No sooner as an elderly patient booked in to the reception desk than thoughts turn to whether or not shes an appropriate attendance. For Mrs Smith, an 87- year old grandmother of four who worked as a nurse here for decades, thats hardly an issue. Shes poorly and, whatever the context, has, by arriving at your unit, declared a need for help. And thats absolutely appropriate.

Picking up her notes you reflect on what the role of primary care could, should or might be in her management. But thats a difficult judgment because you dont really know what primary care really means. Is it a GP? A district nurse? A therapist? Or is it just anything which doesnt involve a hospital? It must be different to general practice because that is a separate label. It doesnt matter to Mrs Smith nor should it. But we make it matter to ourselves. She has only been in the building for twenty minutes and already she is an inappropriate primary care attendance.

Assessment reveals a respiratory tract infection and in all probability things can be managed without the need for an admission. But someone somewhere has already taken some blood samples on Mrs Smith. And our inappropriate primary care attendance is now also waiting for bloods. Nobody quite knows why this is so, but the blood tests have been taken so we may as well await their return. Mrs Smith is 87 and her blood indices will not have been normal since 1995. But that isnt really noticed.

There is no surprise to discover that her U&E results are not deemed satisfactory. Although she in herself is keen to go home, its Friday, and because the out of hours service isnt yet operational, yet the GP surgery has no appointments to offer, it seems best just to run this case past the medical team. Theyre busy, of course, and so Mrs Smith is now not only an inappropriate primary care attendance who awaited bloods, shes now a breach because of capacity challenges.

In fact, such is the delay to be seen that Mrs Smith, who still really wants to go home before it gets dark, is now almost a 12 hour trolley wait. She is comfortable enough; space is available to care for her in a rapidly-cleaned cubicle. And, by and by, a bed is identified on an outlier ward for her. If only there was an outlier doctor free to see her. But there isnt. The next day is a Saturday and nobody thinks that Mrs Smith will manage unless she has a commode and a carer to put her to bed. She herself thinks shell be fine. But what she doesnt know is that shed steadily becoming a bed blocker because no carer can be had until Monday.

Come Monday, Mrs Smith goes home. She came seeking help because she thought that was the right thing to do. Her chest infection is getting better, but there is much more to it than that. Without even trying, this elderly lady, who worked here all those years ago, has been inappropriate, a product of failed primary care, has waited for bloods, been a breach, a 12 hour trolley wait, an outlier, and a bed blocker.

48 hours ago, she was just a retired old lady who felt unwell.

The vital elements of care are lost in translation as we rush to describe models premised upon meaningless labels. We dont even know what they mean. Words matter. We must do better.

Other items you may enjoy

The 3Cs of Paediatrics Author: Elizabeth Herrieven / Editor: Charlotte Davies / Codes: / Published: 12/03/2019 It's Friday evening and you're at work in the ED (where else...
Emergency Casebook: Its Cold Outside The content you're about to read or listen to is at least two years old, which means evidence and guidelines may have changed since it was originally ...
Major Incidents Part 1 The content you're about to read or listen to is at least two years old, which means evidence and guidelines may have changed since it was originally ...

Leave a Reply